| pick | Team | Rookie | Pos | College | Cut |
| 5 | Maddogs | Keon Humpries | DB | Mississippi State | |
| 14 | Muli | Anthony Hines | DB | Texas Tech | |
| 15 | Saints | Malcom Jenkins | DB | Ohio State | |
| 16 | Doves | Troy Nolan | DB | Arizona State | |
| 19 | Seamen (from Frogs) | Kenny Ingram | DB | Florida State | |
| 20 | Black Knights | Aqib Talib | DB | Kansas | |
| 39 | Saints | Brandon Harrison | DB | Michigan | |
| 44 | Hurricanes | Jack Ikegwuonu | DB | Wisconsin | Danny Farmer, DB |
| 1 | Royal Dodgers | Benjamin Lampkin | DL | Florida State | |
| 2 | Muli | Mike Graise | DL | Washington State | |
| 9 | Daemons | Charles Burns | DL | Mississippi State | |
| 30 | Rhinos | Donald Horton | DL | Arizona | |
| 34 | Hurricanes | Jim McGillicuddy | DL | Stanford | |
| 46 | Guelfi | Ron Brace | DL | Boston College | |
| 3 | Saints | Tyler Wortman | LB | Nebraska | |
| 10 | Hurricanes | Anthony Littlejohn | LB | Mississippi State | |
| 11 | Seamen | Calen Shearer | LB | Texas Tech | |
| 17 | Maddogs | Marcus Washington | LB | Georgia | |
| 24 | Guelfi | Jerod Mayo | LB | Tennessee | |
| 26 | Muli | Johnny Williams | LB | Kentucky | |
| 31 | Frogs | Derry Beckwitt | LB | Louisiana State | |
| 35 | Seamen | Brad Jones | LB | Colorado | |
| 41 | Maddogs | Merrill Johnson | LB | Auburn | |
| 50 | Guelfi | Joe Mortensen | LB | Kansas | Simone Borsi, LB |
| 25 | Royal Dodgers | Austin Panter | LB | Michigan | |
| 4 | Doves | Pete Cunningham | OL | Mississippi State | |
| 6 | Rhinos | Milt Machu | OL | Florida State | |
| 21 | Daemons | Cameron Hoskins | OL | Auburn | |
| 22 | Hurricanes | Robert Baylor | OL | Oklahoma | |
| 29 | Maddogs | Mike Banks | OL | Stanford | |
| 38 | Muli | Kenneth Black | OL | Kentucky | |
| 48 | Guelfi | Leon Smith | OL | Georgia | |
| 13 | Seamen (from RD) | Christopher Richards | OL | Georgia Tech | |
| 42 | Rhinos | Jason Ricks | P | Oklahoma State | |
| 12 | Guelfi | Graham Harrell | QB | Texas Tech | Tee Martin, QB |
| 33 | Daemons | John Parker-Wilson | QB | Alabama | |
| 7 | Frogs | Cody Glenn | RB | Nebraska | |
| 18 | Rhinos | Javon Ringer | RB | Michigan State | |
| 36 | Guelfi | Brandon Hart | RB | Mississippi State | |
| 40 | Doves | Terry Longbons | RB | Arizona | |
| 49 | Seamen | Josh Catron | RB | Stanford | |
| 32 | Black Knights | Tommy Trott | TE | Auburn | |
| 43 | Frogs | Hunter Teafatiller | TE | Nebraska | |
| 47 | Seamen | Rory Nicol | TE | Ohio State | Casey Tate, TE |
| 8 | Black Knights | Cody Crawford | WR | Colorado | |
| 23 | Seamen | Austin Rogers | WR | Tennessee | |
| 27 | Saints | Kelton Lynn | WR | Stanford | |
| 28 | Doves | Todd Nelson | WR | Oklahoma State | |
| 37 | Royal Dodgers | DeSean Jackson | WR | California | |
| 45 | Royal Dodgers (from Sea) | LaTerryal Savoy | WR | Michigan |